| YEAR | PLAYER | SCHOOL | DIVISION |
| 2019 | Taylor Jackson | University of Illinois | NCAA l |
| 2019 | Levi Usher | University of Louisville | NCAA l |
| 2019 | Cameron Leff | Indiana State University | NCAA l |
| 2019 | Zion Pettigrew | University of South Alabama | NCAA l |
| 2019 | Austin Krob | Texas Christian University | NCAA l |
| 2019 | Carter Lawler | Eastern Illinois University | NCAA l |
| 2019 | Kal Youngquist | University of Illinois - Springfield | NCAA l |
| 2019 | Cam Cowan | Campbell University | NCAA l |
| 2019 | Joel Thompson | Mt Mercy University | NAIA |
| 2019 | Skylar Frese | Mt Mercy University | NAIA |
| 2019 | Brennan Brister | ||
| 2018 | Ellison Hanna | Indiana State University | NCAA l |
| 2018 | Izaya Fullard | University of Iowa | NCAA l |
| 2018 | Cal Clark | Houston Baptist | NCAA l |
| 2018 | Korry Howell | University of Iowa | NCAA l |
| 2108 | Chili Moseley | Mount Mercy University | NAIA |
| 2018 | Peyton Long | Central Methodist University | NAIA |
| 2018 | Nate Barnes | Mount Mercy University | NAIA |
| 2018 | Kaden Wadle | Western Illinois University | NCAA l |
| 2018 | Cal Stalzer | George Washington University | NCAA l |
| 2018 | Adam Ketelsen | University of Iowa | NCAA l |
| 2018 | Max McCay | Central Methodist University | NAIA |
| 2018 | Spencer Wiskus | Indiana State University | NCAA l |
| 2018 | Ross Kramer | Indiana State University | NCAA l |
| 2018 | Jake Mclaughlin | University of Iowa | NCAA l |
| 2018 | Hunter Lee | University of Iowa | NCAA l |
| 2018 | Manny Olutunde | Mount Mercy University | NAIA |
| 2018 | Brandon Sanchez | Chicago State University | NCAA l |
| 2017 | Lorenzo Elion | University of Iowa | NCCA l |
| 2017 | Colin Kreiter | University of Wisconsin - Milwaukee | NCAA l |
| 2017 | Tyler Bordner | University of Wisconsin - Milwaukee | NCAA l |
| 2017 | General Mcarthur | Missouri Baptist University | NAIA |
| 2017 | Toran Shahidi | USC-Upstate University | NCAA l |
| 2017 | Joey Verstegen | Mount Mercy University | NAIA |
| 2017 | Corbin Day | Mount Mercy University | NAIA |
| 2017 | Joe Funkhouser | Northwest Missouri State University | NCAA ll |
| 2017 | Austin Miller | University of Mississippi | NCAA l |
| 2017 | Brody Alberts | Mount Mercy University | NAIA |
| 2017 | Brock Adams | Mount Mercy University | NAIA |
| 2017 | Bo Greenlee | Wartburg College | NCAA lll |
| 2016 | Jeffrey Castillo | Central Methodist University | NAIA |
| 2016 | Jamison Steege | Southern Illinois University | NCAA l |
| 2016 | Nick Bruno | Nebraska Wesleyan University | NCAA lll |
| 2016 | JT Sole | California State University-San Marcos | NCAA ll |
| 2016 | Zachary Morrissey | Maryville University | NCAA ll |
| 2016 | Jack Fitzgerald | Houston Baptist University | NCAA I |
| 2016 | Matt Paciello | Chicago State University | NCAA I |
| 2016 | Ethan Howard | University of Illinois-Springfield | NCAA ll |
| 2016 | Jay Campbell | Loras College | NCAA lll |
| 2016 | Bryce Grimm | Illinois State University | NCAA l |
| 2016 | Tyler Butz | University of Colorado-Colorado Springs | NCAA ll |
| 2016 | Ben Milks | Loras College | NCAA lll |
| 2016 | Nolan Even | Loras College | NCAA lll |
| 2016 | Emanuel Castellano | University of Cumberlands | NAIA |
| 2016 | Luke Hassman | Northwest Missouri State University | NCAA ll |
| 2015 | Sulliam Rios Reyes | Tennessee Wesleyan University | NAIA |
| 2015 | Ozzie Adams | Northwest Missouri State University | NCAA ll |
| 2015 | Zach Patterson | University of Illinois-Springfield | NCAA ll |
| 2015 | Hayden Sloane | University of Science and Arts of Oklahoma | NAIA |
| 2015 | Randy Perez | Central Methodist University | NAIA |
| 2015 | Adam Marra | Mount Mercy | NAIA |
| 2014 | Shane Kemp | George Washington University | NCAA l |