| YEAR | NAME | AWARD | ASSOCIATION |
| 2017 | Louis Flynn | Honorable Mention All-American | NJCAA |
| 2016 | Carson Whittington | 1st Team All-American | NJCAA |
| 2016 | Charlie Hartwig | 2nd Team All-American | NJCAA |
| 2016 | Jordan Even | Honorable Mention All-American | NJCAA |
| 2013 | Nathan Chilcott | Honorable Mention All-American | NJCAA |
| 2013 | Sean Cleary | 1st Team All-American | NJCAA |
| 2013 | Jordan Azbell | 2nd Team All-American | NJCAA |
| 2012 | Mitch Jacobi | Honorable Mention All-American | NJCAA |
| 2006 | Cedric Bertin | 1st Team All-American | NJCAA |
| 2006 | T.J. Redding | 1st Team All-American | NJCAA |
| 2004 | T.J. Redding | 1st Team All-American | NJCAA |
| 2002 | Eric Cress | Honorable Mention All-American | NJCAA |
| 2001 | Cade Pleggenkuhle | 3rd Team All-American | NJCAA |
| 2000 | Cade Pleggenkuhle | 1st Team All-American | NJCAA |